NYINC 2020... Three books, three coins and two cookies

One destination that had been on my bucket list for ages is New York - walk across the Brooklyn Bridge, catch a ferry to Staten Island, go up the Empire State Building, see the treasures in the Met, jog in Central Park and so on.   Finally, in 2016 an excuse arose to go - a group of Roman Republican coin collectors invited me along to their annual brunch at the New York International Numismatic Convention (NYINC).   The NYINC is a Mecca for ancient coin collectors with auctions, lectures and a large coin fair, lasting three or four days - 3 if you pay $20 ($15 if you print and bring along a coupon on the nyinc.info website) or 4 if you pay $125 for an early bird ticket to get in on the Thursday before the hoi polloi.

Discount coupon printed and packed, I was in the 3-day group

In 2016, I went for 3 nights, spent all my money, met some of the Uber collectors and saw the sights.

There were over 100 dealers, spread all over the wonderful Art Deco Waldorf Astoria hotel.   I missed 2017, but made it again in 2018 and 2019.   In 2018, I found the best pizzeria in maybe the world, Juliana's in Brooklyn.   In 2019, I spent four nights there, dragging Annie along too.   We saw Carrie Bradshaw's apartment and went to a great jazz gig with the Jimmy Heath Big Band - he was in his 90s and had played with many of the greats in a long career since the 1940s.   Sadly, Jimmy passed away later in 2019, so we can only hope he's playing with them again.   In fact, I only spent one hour at the actual coin fair    From 2018, the NYINC has found a new home in the Grand Hyatt, beside Grand Central Terminal - the Waldorf is under refurbishment and may be more apartments than hotel when it reopens, so the Hyatt will remain the show's home.

Roll on the the 2020 event - this time travelling on my own again (NY in January is too cold for some) and back to a two-night trip.   The plan was to fly over on the Friday morning, catch the fair on the Friday afternoon, the lunch on the Saturday, back to the fair and fly back on the Sunday night and straight to the office on Monday morning

Logistically, everything went perfectly - United from Dublin to Newark (previously, I'd gone to JFK with Delta), a train from the airport to Penn Station and a short walk to my hotel.

As a coin collector, one of the first things one notices in the U.S. is that notes are used much more than coins.   While Ireland switched to the £1 coin in 1990 and we now have €1 and €2 coins, the $1 note or bill is very much alive and well in the U.S.   The U.S. has minted billions of $1 coins in recent years, but they hardly circulate, being mostly encountered in vending machines.   Within minutes of arriving at the airport, I had acquired nine $1 coins from such a machine - a selection of presidential dollars, two Sacagawea dollars and a Susan B. Anthony dollar, the first of the modern small dollar coins.   The Susan B. Anthony dollar, minted only for four years - 1979 - 1981 and 1999, is cupro-nickel with a solid copper core, while the later dollars are also clad, but of brass over a copper core.   The weights and electrical properties of these types of dollars are all the same, so they should all work in vending machines.   The failure of the Suzie B to become a popular circulating coin was blamed on its similarity in size and colour to the 25c (quarter) coin, though it is larger and noticeably heavier.   The more recent dollars are all a brassy colour and so unlikely to be mistaken for quarters, but are no more popular.

Anyway, with pockets jingling, I hopped on a train and thanks to the miracle of timezones was in Manhattan by 12.20 on what was a lovely crisp clear January afternoon.

Luckily, I could check in at my hotel close to Bryant Park, only a 10-minute walk from Penn Station.   After a short siesta it was time to tackle the fair.

Registering involves producing photo' ID and getting a badge to wear around one's neck - this year, they got my name right, previously my middle name has served as a surname for the duration as I didn't notice that they'd misread my passport until I was happily wearing my new badge.

Unfortunately, I have no photos from inside the fair - but there were over 100 dealers, all selling ancient and foreign (i.e. non-U.S.) coins.   The first day, I got a coin and a book and two cookies - shown in the first photo'.   The coin from our own member, Del Parker, the book, the scarce Lindgren vol. I, covering bronze coins of Asia Minor and the Levant.

The cookies were sold by Alfredo de la Fe of Agora Auctions.   His wife runs a cake decorating business and made several batches of cookies on ancient coin themes.   I believe she projected images of coins onto the cookies and iced them by hand.   I got two - the Akragas "tetradrachm" and the equally delicious Carthaginian stater below, with the prototype coin!   The cookies got a little squashed on the return flight, but still tasted great :)

I didn't have a whole lot of time on the Friday, so went back to the hotel, dropped off my purchases and went in search of food and books.   Strand Books, close to Union Square (it's at Broadway and E 12th Street), has 18 miles of bookshelves and many bargains.   There are racks of books outside for $1 - $4 and many more inside.   I picked up two books about telescopes and physics and repaired to a small pizza place where I stuffed my face with a couple of slices.

On Saturday, I had a walk along the High Line in the morning - it was nice, rather bracing walk in the fairly cold morning - I'm sure it's much more pleasant in summer!

I met with the usual gang of collectors for lunch - about a dozen of us this time, who'd brought along some prizes from the last year.   It was good to see everyone again and catch up and see some treasures.   I'd brought along a few recent acquisitions too - this is about the best of them, a denarius of 64 BC from the Mesagne Hoard found in 1980:

Most of the others at lunch are US-based, with one other Irish guy, though he's now based in London.   A high percentage of us were engineers of one shade or other - maybe there's a connection between collecting and engineering.   After about three hours of eating, drinking and passing around coins it was time to go into the snow again (it had started snowing shortly before lunch) and back to the fair.

Back at the fair I picked up two denarii from Harlan J. Berk and two books from Oliver Hoover's series Handbook of Greek Coinage (shown in the first picture) from Charles Davis.

Then back to the hotel to deposit the purchases and prepare for one of my favourite haunts in NY...

I discovered Juliana's in 2018 - my youngest sister spent a summer in New York on a J1 visa in 2001, just getting home before the September 11 attacks - since then, she has raved about the city and has been back a few times.   She insisted I go to try a pizza in Grimaldi's in Brooklyn.   Well, in 2016, I tried, but ended up in a Chinese restaurant instead    In 2018, I crossed the bridge and found Grimaldi's - found it to be closed for Christmas holidays.   However, almost next door was Juliana's pizza, with a queue of people snaking back in -7C temperatures.   So, I queued and, because I was on my own, they led me through to sit at the counter beside the pizza oven.   The pizza was wonderful - I returned to the hotel stuffed but happy and with half the pizza left to eat cold in the morning.   I looked up Juliana's on the web and discovered that Patsy Grimaldi, of Grimaldi's pizzeria, had sold his business and retired.   Grimaldi's had outgrown its original premises and moved to the larger building next door and, later again, Patsy had decided he wanted to get back into the pizza business.   His old restaurant was again empty, so he opened up there, under his mother's name.

So, I'd ended up in the place Aoife had recommended, under the same management, but a new name!   Tripadvisor users, I found, had rated Juliana's as the top pizzeria in the U.S. in 2015.   I was a big fan of Dublin's Pizza Stop - since it closed, I have to go to New York for good pizza    I returned with Annie in 2019 where she proclaimed the coffee to be up to standard, unlike the watery brown liquid served in most of New York.

Anyway, I'm a creature of habit, so had to return for more pizza.   I caught a subway to the Manhattan end of the Brooklyn Bridge, walked across - looking back towards lower Manhattan, you can just see the Statue of Liberty in the distance here - and made my way to Juliana's.

Juliana's is close to the bridge and there was no queue this time, so soon I was seated at the counter and tucking into this!

It's as good as ever, I can confirm.

And that was it.   I didn't go back to the fair on the Sunday - instead I went to Central Park, bought a camera lens in B&H and had a good walk around.   On Sunday evening, I caught the flight back to Dublin and didn't quite make it to directly to work on the Monday morning - I went home to lie down first!

What I collect

More than a year since my last blog post - sorry, folks!

So, maybe time for a different style of post - what do we collect and why?   In the last few years, I've collected mainly Roman Republican coins, but I have plenty of other collecting areas.

One long-term interest is in ancient Greek coins of the Classical era - the coins of the city states, which bear the emblems of their cities - the owls of Athens, mentioned in an earlier post, turtles of Aegina, Pegasus on the coins of Corinth and so on.   The numismatic art of some of the late fifth/early fourth century BC Sicilian coins remains unequalled and I have been lucky enough to pick up a few fairly worn specimens.

Other collecting interests are more transitory, but just as rewarding - here's one.

In the summer of 2007, I spent a few days in Girona, in Spain's Catalunya region and while driving one day spotted a sign "Ruinas".   It turned out to be the remains of the Greek (and later Roman) town of Emporion - Empúries.

It was an idyllic summer day by the sea -

Asclepius statue, Emporion

Emporion ruins by the sea

Floor mosaic, Emporion

Forum, Emporion

As a coin collector, the obvious question for me was "Did Emporion mint coins?".   Indeed it did - the Greek city was a major trading centre and minted drachms and fractions, which were later copied by other Iberian cities in the area.   The on-site museum had some modern reproductions on sale, but I wanted something original and it took me about 3 years to get what I wanted :)

In 2009, at the Real Casa de la Moneda shop in Madrid Airport (I don't think the mint has a shop there any more), I found this modern €10 coin, part of a series "Joyas Numismaticas" which reuses ancient and mediaeval Spanish coin designs on modern commemorative coins.

Modern Spanish €10 coin reproducing drachm of Emporion

This coin reproduces a drachm of Emporion with the head of Arethusa on the obverse with three dolphins around and Pegasus on the reverse.   In common with many of the ancient drachms of Emporion, the head of Pegasus is formed by Chrysaor - in Greek mythology Chrysaor was the brother of Pegasus.

This was a start, but I wanted some ancient coins.   I contacted a Spanish dealer and, by chance, on his desk he had half a drachm:

Cut drachm of Emporion

This was a drachm of Emporion from sometime before 250 BC, but was obviously cut in ancient times to circulate as a half drachm.   I got this in July 2009.

Emporion Hemitrietartermorion

Next, in October 2009, on eBay from the same seller I got this fraction - a tiny 0.15g 7.5mm hemitritetartermorion.   This is quite a scarce little coin.

Emporion drachms and their contemporary copies are fairly common in Spanish auctions and finally in December 2010 I got one:

Emporion Drachm

This was struck from fairly worn dies (especially the reverse) and the reverse is somewhat off-centre, so there's room for improvement.

Books on ancient coins are a close second in interest to the coins themselves - to properly catalogue these, I bought Alvarez-Burgos - "La Moneda Hispánica, desde sus orígenes hasta el siglo V" and, recently, a Forni reprint of Alois Heiss's 1870 work "Description générale des monnaies antiques de l'Espagne".

So - a chance encounter with some ruins and a very pleasant day wandering through them has resulted in the purchase of four coins and two books.   Maybe someday I'll get a stunning drachm, but for now the 2010 purchase is OK.

More Later Republican Denarii

Quintus Pomponius Musa

As we saw in a previous blog post, exactly a year ago, on 20th March, 2015, moneyers of the later Republican period exercised considerable freedom in designing the coinage and changed the designs every year, using the post as an opportunity to publicise an ancestor or indeed whatever took their fancy.

The topic of this post is the series of coins issued by Quintus Pomponius Musa in 66BC (date according to Crawford, Harlan dates the issue to 65BC).

While some moneyers went on to achieve fame or infamy in later life, Q. Pomponius Musa is unknown aside from his coins.   The gens Pomponia was an ancient Roman family, claiming descent from Pompo, a son of Numa, Rome's second king.   In any case, our Q. Pomponius Musa seems have issued coins featuring the Muses because muse rhymes with Musa.

Nine Muses are featured, each engaged in the activity for which she was known in the ancient world, plus Hercules.   So far, I've managed to acquire four of the Muses, plus Hercules; so, my collection is half-complete :)

The obverse of the coins is generally said to feature Apollo, with a different symbol associated with the Muse on the reverse, but Harlan claims that it's not the head of Apollo but a generic Muse.   I'd tend to agree with this, as the head is quite feminine, even for Apollo.   The coin featuring Hercules does have the head of Apollo on the obverse.   Apollo is normally regarded as the leader of the Muses, but in Rome there was a temple with statues of the nine Muses in the temple of Hercules - the statues of the Muses were taken as booty from the Greek city of Ambracia following its surrender to the Romans after a siefe in 189 BC.   The consul Fulvius Nobilior took over 1000 statues from the city and paraded them through Rome in his triumph in 187 BC.   At the same time as dedicating the statues of the Muses, Nobilior seems to have moved a shrine to the Camenae, obscure Goddesses which had become associated with the Muses, to the temple of Hercules.   This shrine had originally been dedicated by Numa, claimed ancestor of the Pomponii.   Harlan speculates that our Pomponius was associating his family with an original shrine of the Muses.

I've mentioned Crawford and Harlan in this post; next time, I'll give a bibliography for Roman Republican coins which will give an idea of what to read for more information.

Muses and their attributes

• Calliope - Lyric Poetry

• Cleio - History

• Melpomene - Tragedy

• Erato - Erotic Poetry

• Terpischore - Dance (Tortoise behind head)

  
  

  

• Euterpe - Lyric Poetry (crossed flutes behind head)

  

• Urania - Astronomy (star behind head)

  

• Thalia - Comedy

• Polymnia - Rhetoric (wreath behind head)

  

• Hercules - Leader of the Muses

  

   

   

Back to posting soon - honest!

I hadn't meant to stop posting suddenly - I had at least one or two more posts left on the Roman Republican coins, but I got distracted and drifted away from it.

Most of the photos have disappeared - I'll upload them again.

Anyway, I promise to resume posting either tomorrow or Monday, so watch this space!

Later Denarii

Later Denarii

As we saw last time, the designs used on the main silver coins - denarii, quinarii & sestertii were all similar - helmeted head of Roma on the obverse and the Dioscuri on the reverse.   The early coins are all anonymous, not carrying the names of the moneyers.   Later, the moneyers started putting abbreviated versions of their names on the coins, like this example of Lucius Cupiennius from 147 BC.   At this stage, the design is the traditional Dioscuri.

On the reverse, the inscription reads L. CVP (VP written in ligature format), with ROMA in the exergue.   Note that in Latin, there is no distinction between U and V.

The other design commonly featured at this time has Victory in a biga on the reverse:

The example above is from Pinarius Natta, of 149 BC.   The moneyer's name is written as NATTA, with the second T and the final A superimposed.

At around the same time, in 141 BC, the denarius was retariffed to 16 asses, from 10.   Initially, the mark of value, X, was changed to XVI from X, as shown here on this denarius from 141 BC.

This particular coin is from Lucius Julius.   The XVI mark didn't last long in use - it was largely replaced by an X with a horizontal bar through it - believed to be a monogram of XVI.   In fact, on later issues, the X is often used again.

While the earlier coins with moneyers' names are of conventional types with names added, later types have designs apparently chosen by the moneyers themselves.   These often referred to heroic or imaginary deeds by their ancestors, as well as to current events.   Some examples...

This coin is by Caius Mamilius Limetanus and dates from 82 BC.   The obverse features Mercury with a caduceus (staff).   The reverse has Ulysses returning from the Trojan War after 20 years, meeting his faithful dog Argos, who is the only one to recognise him in disguise.   The moneyer claimed to be descended from Ulysses and through him, from Mercury.

This type from 63 BC and features Vesta on the obverse and a voting scene on the reverse.   The voter is dropping a tablet inscribed V (for "Vti rogas") into a cista.   This is believed to refer to an ancestor of the moneyer, Lucius Cassius Longinus Ravilla, who presided over a commission of investigation of misdeeds by Vestal Virgins in 113 BC (three were executed).   The moneyer himself, another Lucius Cassius Longinus, was the brother of Caius Cassius Longinus, a conspirator in the assassination of Julius Caesar.

It's now late at night here, so more coins will have to wait for the next posting.

Denarius Coinage of 211 BC

Denarius Coinage

The Second Punic War ended with Roman victory, which came at a huge cost, financial was well as human.   During the war, the silver didrachms (quadrigati) were reduced in purity and size and the cast bronze coins (aes grave) reduced in size.


In 211 BC (the exact date of the introduction of the denarius was debated in the past, but most now accept 211 BC), a major reform of the coinage was enacted.   The debased quadrigati were replaced by a 10-as coin called the Denarius; there was a 5-as coin, the Quinarius and a 2.5-as coin, the Sestertius.   Additionally, there was another silver denomination, the Victoriatus (the name of this coin isn't known from antiquity, its modern name derives from its featuring Victory with a trophy on the reverse).   For the bronze coins, the as was now a struck coin of about 50g, with fractions - semis, triens, quadrans, sextans, uncia as before.   For a short time, gold coins were struck, in 20-, 40- and 60-as denominations.

Here's an early denarius

And a quinarius:

 And a sestertius:

There's a uniform design across the three main silver denominations - Roma in helmet on the obverse and the Dioscuri (Castor and Pollux) riding on the reverse.   Marks of value are on the obverse - X for ten asses, V for five and II S for 2.5 asses (two asses plus one semis).   The denarius initially weighed about 4.5g, the quinarius 2.2g and the sestertius 1.1g.

The bronze coins of the period had standard designs too - the prow of a galley on the reverse, with different obverse types and value marks, depending on the denomination:

• Janus - as - I
• Saturn - semis - S
• Minerva - triens - four pellets
• Hercules - quadrans - three pellets
• Mercury - sextans - two pellets
• Roma - uncia - one pellet

Examples of these coins are below:

The as - this is a relatively early example, well-worn.   There is a I over the Janiform heads and a dolphin symbol on the reverse, to the right of the galley:

A semis - S to the left of Saturn and over the galley on the reverse

A triens - four pellets above Minerva and under the galley:

A quadrans - three pellets behind Hercules and below the galley:

 A sextans - two pellets above Mercury and two under the galley.   There is also a letter L between the pellets on the reverse.   This signifies the mint where the coin was minted - Luceria:

And finally, the uncia - a single pellet behind Roma and under the galley.   I may be cheating here - this uncia probably pre-dates the denarius coinage :)

For nearly 20 years there were no innovations in the coin designs - the designs were fixed apart from symbols which were sometimes used - for example, the denarius above has a staff under the horses and the as has the dolphin.

In 194 BC, a change to the reverse was made - the Dioscuri were replaced by Luna driving a biga (chariot pulled by two horses) and later Victory driving a biga was tried.   Shortly after, the moneyers for each year started to put abbreviated versions of their names on the coins and then to change the designs each year.   The organisation of the Roman mint was such that three officials were appointed to oversee it each year, for a one-year term.   It wasn't a very high-ranking post - some moneyers went on to greater things, while others are known only from their coins.

Tune in next time for some of the more exciting later denarius issues :D

Roman Republican Coins

Roman Republican Coins

Yesterday's entry finished with the first silver coin struck for Rome, a didrachm (two drachma piece).
These coins were probably struck around 280 BC to pay for Rome's war against Tarentum and Pyrrhus, king of Epirus in Greece who came to the aid of the Greek colonies in Italy and is best remembered today for the term "Pyrrhic Victory".

As well as the Mars/horsehead didrachm, other types were struck with Apollo and Hercules on the obverse and a horse or wolf & twins on the reverse.

This is one of the slightly later types, with Apollo and a horse.   The legend is now ROMA, not ROMANO - it's now the name of the city, not "of the Romans", which was a more Greek-style legend.


Beneath is a struck bronze coin of the period (~300 BC to ~230 BC):

These were token coins (i.e. they circulated for a value in excess of their metal value) and probably were mainly used for trade with southern Italian cities, which wouldn't have used the much heavier cast bronze coins.

At around 225 BC, a design change took place, with the obverse now featuring a Janus head and the reverse Jupiter driving a quadriga (chariot drawn by four horses).   This change in design took place at the same time as a change to the designs of the cast bronze coins (aes grave).   These now featured a Janus head on the obverse of the as (the 1 pound coin) and the prow of a galley on the reverse.   Smaller bronze coins had different heads, but the prow reverse was standard.

This is an example of a later didrachm, the so-called quadrigatus - named for the quadriga on the reverse.   These initially weighed more than 6g and were of fine silver, but during the Second Punic War became lighter and made from debased silver as the Roman coffers ran low.   During this period, the coin was probably worth 6 asses (plural of as).

Drachm coins are less common - these are half the weight and have Jupiter driving left rather than right.

I don't have an example of an aes grave as, but here's a sextans (1/6th of an as):

Mercury is on the obverse (as on all sextantes) - he always is shown with the same winged hat which aids in identification.   There are two pellets below the head and two on the reverse, below the prow of a galley.

The Roman pound was made up of 12 unciae (ounces).   The number of pellets on the coins indicates how many unciae it weighs - a sextans has two pellets and is worth two unciae.   The standard denominations for these case coins were:

• As - initially ~324g, later reduced to ~278g
• Semis (half an as)
• Triens (third of an as)
• Quadrans (quarter of an as)
• Sextans (sixth of an as)
• Uncia (twelfth of an as)

Fractions of an uncia were also made - these were often struck - in fact, some of the smaller denominations were struck rather than cast.

From about 225 BC until after the Second Punic War, these were the coins issued by Rome - silver quadrigati and large cast bronze coins.

The main event in Roman Republican coinage history is the introduction of the Denarius Coinage in 211 BC and that will be the subject of the next post.